Jet2holidays wins on value. Marella vanishes on cruises.
TUI owns the hotels — but AI doesn’t always know it.
Travel agents and corporate buyers researching tour operators across ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude find TUI on 38 of 60 responses (63.3%). That puts TUI ahead of every competitor — but leaves 22 buyer queries where Jet2holidays, Kuoni, or easyJet holidays win the recommendation instead. The biggest blind spot: Marella Cruises is invisible on every cruise query across all three platforms.
The findings below come from Xtrusio, an AI visibility audit system built specifically for buyer-intent testing. Every citation was verified by running 20 real prospect queries across three generative AI platforms.
Methodology calibrated for the leisure travel and tour operator category — testing how AI platforms guide holiday booking decisions for travel agents and consumers.
TUI owns Crystal Ski, ROBINSON, and Marella Cruises — but AI platforms don’t connect the dots.
ChatGPT and Gemini both cite Crystal Ski as the #1 operator for Alps skiing — without identifying it as a TUI brand. Claude calls ROBINSON “a German-owned chain” without linking it to TUI Group. Marella Cruises is invisible on all 3 cruise queries across every platform. The result: TUI’s sub-brands generate AI recommendations that never flow back to the parent brand. Meanwhile, Jet2holidays appears on 30+ of 60 responses — always under one name, always building one brand.
Platform Scorecard
TUI citation rate across AI platforms — and how competitors compare
AI Visibility Leaderboard
Who owns the AI conversation — total citations across all platforms
AI Positioning Audit
20 buyer-intent queries — click any row to see the exact question
Each query was written from the perspective of a travel industry professional evaluating tour operators for client recommendations. These personas represent the agents and buyers whose AI research determines whether TUI gets recommended to holidaymakers.
| # | Query Topic | Cluster | ChatGPT | Claude | Gemini |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | All-Inclusive Turkey, Kids’ Clubs | Family | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
Exact question asked across all AI platforms: “What are the best tour operators for all-inclusive family holidays in Turkey with kids’ clubs and activities included?” | |||||
| 2 | Luxury Honeymoon Maldives | Luxury | ✗ | ✓ | ✗ |
Exact question asked across all AI platforms: “I’m planning a luxury honeymoon in the Maldives and want flights, hotel, and transfers arranged by one company — which operators can handle the whole thing from the UK?” | |||||
| 3 | UK Operators Owning Hotels | Differentiation | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
Exact question asked across all AI platforms: “Which UK holiday companies own their own hotels rather than just reselling other people’s rooms, and does it make a difference to the experience?” | |||||
| 4 | Caribbean Cruise from UK | Cruises | ✓ | ✗ | ✗ |
Exact question asked across all AI platforms: “What’s the best way to book an all-inclusive Caribbean cruise from the UK — should I use a tour operator or book directly with the cruise line?” | |||||
| 5 | Greece Family Package, Value | Value | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
Exact question asked across all AI platforms: “I’m looking for a package holiday to Greece for a family of four this summer with everything included — which operators offer the best value?” | |||||
| 6 | Own Aircraft, Long-Haul | Long-Haul | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
Exact question asked across all AI platforms: “Are there any UK tour operators that fly their own aircraft to long-haul destinations like Mexico, Jamaica, and Thailand?” | |||||
| 7 | TUI/Jet2 vs Booking.com | Comparison | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
Exact question asked across all AI platforms: “What’s the difference between booking a package holiday through TUI or Jet2 versus using Booking.com or Expedia to arrange everything separately?” | |||||
| 8 | Exclusive Hotel Brands Spain | Differentiation | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
Exact question asked across all AI platforms: “Which all-inclusive hotel brands in Spain and the Canary Islands are exclusive to specific tour operators and not available to book independently?” | |||||
| 9 | First Med Cruise, UK Ports | Cruises | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ |
Exact question asked across all AI platforms: “I’m a couple in our fifties looking to try our first Mediterranean cruise — what are the most recommended cruise lines that depart from UK ports?” | |||||
| 10 | Budget Last-Minute Spain | Budget | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ |
Exact question asked across all AI platforms: “What are the best budget-friendly last-minute holiday deals for beach holidays in Spain or Portugal right now?” | |||||
| 11 | Best Customer Service UK | Service | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ |
Exact question asked across all AI platforms: “Which tour operator has the best customer service reputation for UK package holidays?” | |||||
| 12 | Multi-Generational Tenerife | Family | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
Exact question asked across all AI platforms: “I want to take my elderly parents and our children on a multi-generational holiday to Tenerife — which operators specialise in hotels that cater to all age groups?” | |||||
| 13 | Sustainability, European Operators | Sustainability | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
Exact question asked across all AI platforms: “How do European tour operators compare for sustainability and environmentally responsible travel?” | |||||
| 14 | Premium Activity/Sports Resorts | Luxury | ✓ | ✗ | ✗ |
Exact question asked across all AI platforms: “Are there premium activity-focused resort holidays available where you can combine sports like tennis, diving, and fitness with a beach break?” | |||||
| 15 | Financial Protection, Safest Booking | Protection | ✗ | ✓ | ✗ |
Exact question asked across all AI platforms: “What’s the safest way to book a family holiday from the UK in terms of financial protection if the company goes bust?” | |||||
| 16 | European River Cruises | Cruises | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ |
Exact question asked across all AI platforms: “Which holiday companies offer river cruises through Europe with everything included — flights, meals, drinks, and excursions?” | |||||
| 17 | Exclusive Resorts Dominican Republic | Differentiation | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
Exact question asked across all AI platforms: “I’m comparing all-inclusive resorts in the Dominican Republic — which operators have exclusive properties there that you can’t book through generic travel sites?” | |||||
| 18 | Adults-Only Med, Fine Dining | Luxury | ✓ | ✗ | ✗ |
Exact question asked across all AI platforms: “What are the best adults-only holiday resorts in the Mediterranean for couples who want fine dining and spa facilities?” | |||||
| 19 | Package vs Separate, Majorca | Value | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
Exact question asked across all AI platforms: “Is it cheaper to book flights and hotels separately or buy a package holiday for a week in Majorca?” | |||||
| 20 | Ski Holidays Alps, UK Operators | Specialty | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
Exact question asked across all AI platforms: “Which UK tour operators are the best for ski holidays in the Alps with flights and transfers included?” | |||||
| TOTAL | 15/20 (75%) | 13/20 (65%) | 10/20 (50%) | ||
The Gemini Blackout
Where TUI loses 25 percentage points vs ChatGPT — and who takes those queries instead
Gemini cites TUI on just 10 of 20 queries (50%) compared to ChatGPT’s 75%. The 10 queries Gemini misses aren’t random — they cluster around cruises, luxury, customer service, and specialty travel. On these queries, Jet2holidays, Club Med, and P&O Cruises take the recommendations TUI should own.
“I’m a couple in our fifties looking to try our first Mediterranean cruise — what are the most recommended cruise lines that depart from UK ports?”
“Are there premium activity-focused resort holidays where you can combine sports like tennis, diving, and fitness with a beach break?”
“What are the best adults-only holiday resorts in the Mediterranean for couples who want fine dining and spa facilities?”
TUI’s content exists. ChatGPT knows it — citing TUI on 75% of queries with 9 #1 rankings. But Gemini doesn’t. The gap isn’t about product availability — ROBINSON, Marella, Crystal Ski, and Sensatori all exist and serve real customers. The gap is about whether Google’s AI can connect TUI’s sub-brand content to TUI Group’s parent brand when answering buyer questions.
AI Topic Authority Map
Query heatmap — product line × platform
| Topic | AI Leader | TUI Status |
|---|---|---|
| All-Inclusive Family (Turkey/Greece) | TUI | UNANIMOUS (3/3) |
| Owned Hotel Brands | TUI | UNANIMOUS (3/3) |
| Own Aircraft / Long-Haul | TUI | UNANIMOUS (3/3) |
| Exclusive Hotels Spain/DR | TUI | UNANIMOUS (3/3) |
| Multi-Generational Holidays | TUI | UNANIMOUS (3/3) |
| Sustainability | TUI | UNANIMOUS (3/3) |
| Mediterranean Cruises | P&O Cruises | INVISIBLE (0/3) |
| River Cruises | Viking / Scenic | INVISIBLE (0/3) |
| Customer Service Reputation | Jet2holidays | INVISIBLE (0/3) |
| Premium Activity Resorts | Club Med | ChatGPT only (1/3) |
| Luxury Honeymoon | Kuoni | Claude only (1/3) |
| Adults-Only Mediterranean | Ikos / Iberostar | ChatGPT only (1/3) |
| Ski Holidays Alps | Crystal Ski (TUI…) | 2 of 3 — unattributed |
6 queries
5 queries
3 queries
2 queries
4 queries
▹ Cruises is TUI’s weakest product line — Marella Cruises is invisible on Claude and Gemini entirely, and appears on only 1 of 3 ChatGPT cruise queries.
Methodology
How we conducted this Xtrusio AEO/GEO Audit
This research is based on Xtrusio’s proprietary AI visibility analysis framework.
Recommendations
Prioritized actions to close the Gemini gap and fix the attribution leak
- Publish a comprehensive “Marella Cruises — TUI’s All-Inclusive UK Cruise Line” pillar page explicitly connecting Marella to TUI Group with structured data markup
- Add “Part of TUI Group” structured attribution to every Marella Cruises, Crystal Ski, and ROBINSON sub-brand page — schema.org parentOrganization markup
- Create a “TUI Group Brands” hub page listing all sub-brands with descriptions, links, and parent-child relationship signals for AI crawlers
- Publish comparison content: “ROBINSON vs Club Med — Which Premium Activity Resort Is Right for You?” to challenge Club Med’s AI dominance on activity/sports queries
- Create adults-only comparison guides for Sensatori vs Ikos vs Iberostar — targeting the Q18 gap where TUI is invisible on Claude and Gemini
- Address the customer service perception gap (Q11) — publish independent review aggregation data, Which? response, and Trustpilot trend improvements
- Implement cross-brand content strategy: every sub-brand page, press release, and editorial mention should reinforce “TUI Group” parentage to prevent brand equity leakage across all AI platforms
- Quarterly Xtrusio re‑audits to track Marella Cruises visibility recovery, ROBINSON attribution improvement, and Gemini gap closure
Marella is invisible. ROBINSON is orphaned. The fix starts here.
Let’s close TUI’s attribution gap across every AI platform.
This research report was generated using the Xtrusio Company Intelligence Module.
.png)
